Bad Apples

This comes from SHRM Online:

The coughing, sneezing and malaise of flu and cold season can impact the workplace, but bad vibes from one employee are just as contagious, infecting and hurting the rest of the work team, says a new study.

The effect of the “bad apple” employee on co-workers is the subject of a research paper appearing in the December 2006 issue of Research in Organizational Behavior.

“If only for bottom-line reasons, you should pay attention to it because it will have a dramatic impact" on co-workers' job satisfaction, the group's ability to function over time, and the group's productivity and performance,” lead researcher and University of Washington doctoral student William Felps told HR News.

There's a difference, though, between bad apples and employees whose thinking challenges the status quo, something that's not always appreciated, caution Felps and co-researcher Terence Mitchell.

Unlike bad apples, “positive deviants” help spark organizational innovation, they note. “People with divergent ideas can be a real asset to the company or organization. They need managerial protection, not prosecution,” Felps said. Don’t single someone out just because he or she is different, he warns.

Bad apples are employees who do not do their fair share of the work, who are chronically unhappy and emotionally unstable, or who bully or verbally attack people around them, according to Felps and Mitchell.

Check out the whole article. I am guessing that we all knew this and felt this, but this is just more reinforcement that chronic bad behavior - like negativism, complaining, and lack of engagement - affects the whole workplace and is a valid performance problem that needs to be fixed - one way or the other. It is not OK to have people who are destructive to the vibe of the workplace just because they do some other aspects of their jobs very well.

The information in this article is good, but their suggestions seem quite wimpy. They suggest ways to ensure the bad apple has less power over the group. Sure, if you must keep a bad apple, then these coping techniques are worth trying. But as managers and leaders, it is our jobs to ensure that these bad apples become good apples or they become bad apples for someone else.

I have seen this happen MANY times. We finally (months or years late) let the bad apple go and a fog lifts from the entire organization. Think about the opportunity costs that were lost. Being a productive member of the organization is a job duty and requirement. Counseling and/or letting someone go for a destructive communication style is job related and valid. We work in organizations, not collections of individualized work pods.

What if the bad apple is the owner or CEO? Work somewhere else. Don't fool yourself that things will change.

Comments

[laurence haughton]

Here's a suggestion from the article that's a little less wimpy.

"Ideally, though, employers should take special care when it comes to hiring employees... so that those who are really low on agreeableness, emotional stability or conscientiousness are screened out."

It's still slightly wimpy because they included the cop out words "ideally" and "employers." They should have said "Obviously" and "HR" since this was for an HR magazine. I mean if HR can't reliably screen out people with terrible attitudes... who needs them?

[Lisa Haneberg]

I agree! I think we ought to screen potential future bad apples out lickity split. Gone. gonzo. Never makes it to round two.

[Aaron Kassover]

It's a 'bad apple' season! Jodi Taylor made a post yesterday on our blog, Leader's Notebook, with some more suggestions for dealing with bad apples. Take a look: http://www.leadersstudio.com/notebook/archives/39

[Lisa Haneberg]

Aaron - cool, thanks for sharing the link.

[Blaine Collins]

Lisa, Felps and Mitchell started quite a storm of discussion about options for dealing with 'bad apples.'

Their effects can spread like a virus. Fortunately, high morale and positive collaboration can spread just as fast and far!

[Lisa Haneberg]

Thanks, Blaine, and I agree, positive energy is contageous too.

[bkindwhrows]

custumer review acne medicines [url=http://michealcdehart.webs.com/apps/blog/show/9645586-amoxicillin-dosage-for-adults#532] amoxicillin 400mg 50ml dosage for adults [/url] excercises with a medicine ball
compounding pharmacys canada [url=http://michealcdehart.webs.com/apps/blog/show/9645604-amoxicillin-dosage-for-kittens#799] link [/url] chinese medicine fungus
citalopram 20 mg medicine [url=http://michealcdehart.webs.com/apps/blog/show/9645615-amoxicillin-dosage-sore-throat#833] link [/url] river city sports medicine hat
rite aid pharmacy buffalo ny [url=http://michealcdehart.webs.com/apps/blog/show/9645625-amoxicillin-dosage-strep#391] amoxicillin dosage strep throat [/url] foreign pharmacies controlled substances
palm bay florida pharmacy [url=http://michealcdehart.webs.com/apps/blog/show/9645632-amoxicillin-dose-for-uti#544] link [/url] crown pharmacy pills
acid medicine otc pregnant reflux while [url=http://michealcdehart.webs.com/apps/blog/show/9645643-amoxicillin-dosing-chart#076] amoxicillin dosing chart [/url] ammed special operations medicine
dead rising pharmacy [url=http://michealcdehart.webs.com/apps/blog/show/9645651-amoxicillin-for-abcessed-tooth#600] amoxicillin for abcessed tooth [/url] alternative medicine jobs
institute for international medicine [url=http://michealcdehart.webs.com/apps/blog/show/9645664-amoxicillin-for-amoxil#975] amoxicillin for dogs uti amoxil [/url] pharmacist jobs singapore pharmacy
ottoman empire medicine [url=http://michealcdehart.webs.com/apps/blog/show/9645679-amoxicillin-for-bladder-infection#375] amoxicillin for bladder infection [/url] walgreens pharmacy promotion
emergency medicine latest information [url=http://michealcdehart.webs.com/apps/blog/show/9645689-amoxicillin-for-bladder-infections#322] amoxicillin for bladder infections [/url] blake family medicine shallotte
best worm medicine for dogs pharm d online degree
internal medicine doctors tce toxicity minnesota free tests for pharmacy techs
arts and crafts medicine cabinet ocean county sports medicine lakewood
activity for nuclear medicine k mart pharmacy 7340 durham
veterinary acupuncture medicine prerequisites for medicine university entrance
academy medicine national sport windsor pharmacy windsor va
ce pharmacy tech geo medicine medical minral
free discount pharmacy card paoli indiana medicine
toddler cold medicine overseas emergency medicine jobs
joe pet medicine walmart pharmacy beavercreek ohio